The Holy City taproom plays host to themed triva nights on occasion – it’s a thinking man’s (or woman’s) drinking game. With Harry Potter trivia nights on the horizon, we thought it fitting to give a tip of the hat and a wave of the wand to our favorite wizarding beverage: Butterbeer.

We got as close to the real thing as possible, given we’re just a scrappy band of Muggles. I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter Beer is a 5.7% ABV Cream Ale. Smooth, with a silken mouthfeel and a hint of vanilla, we feel like this beer would be right at home in The Three Broomsticks.

(If any of those words make sense to you, join us for Harry Potter trivia!)